iLoungeiLounge
  • News
    • Apple
      • AirPods Pro
      • AirPlay
      • Apps
        • Apple Music
      • iCloud
      • iTunes
      • HealthKit
      • HomeKit
      • HomePod
      • iOS 13
      • Apple Pay
      • Apple TV
      • Siri
    • Rumors
    • Humor
    • Technology
      • CES
    • Daily Deals
    • Articles
    • Web Stories
  • iPhone
    • iPhone Accessories
  • iPad
  • iPod
    • iPod Accessories
  • Apple Watch
    • Apple Watch Accessories
  • Mac
    • MacBook Air
    • MacBook Pro
  • Reviews
    • App Reviews
  • How-to
    • Ask iLounge
Font ResizerAa
iLoungeiLounge
Font ResizerAa
Search
  • News
    • Apple
    • Rumors
    • Humor
    • Technology
    • Daily Deals
    • Articles
    • Web Stories
  • iPhone
    • iPhone Accessories
  • iPad
  • iPod
    • iPod Accessories
  • Apple Watch
    • Apple Watch Accessories
  • Mac
    • MacBook Air
    • MacBook Pro
  • Reviews
    • App Reviews
  • How-to
    • Ask iLounge
Follow US

News › Apple

AppleiPadiPhoneiPod

Judge allows FaceTime lawsuit to proceed

Last updated: May 14, 2021 2:54 pm UTC
By Dan Pye
Judge allows FaceTime lawsuit to proceed

A federal judge has ruled that iPhone 4 and 4s users can pursue their class action lawsuit against Apple for intentionally disabling FaceTime on iOS 6 devices, Reuters reports. After losing a patent lawsuit to VirnetX in 2012, Apple was forced to discontinue its direct device-to-device mode for FaceTime, greatly increasing the fees it had to pay to Akamai Technologies — dropping as much as $50 million in one six-month period according to court documents.


Judge allows FaceTime lawsuit to proceed

In developing iOS 7, Apple engineers were able to include a method of peer-to-peer FaceTime communication that didn’t infringe on the VirnetX patents, however, Apple was either unable to unwilling to bring these improvements into an iOS 6 update. Based on internal emails and sworn testimony from the VirnetX case, the new class-action lawsuit claims that Apple made plans to deliberately “break” FaceTime on older iOS versions by forcing a key digital certificate used for FaceTime to expire prematurely.
The lawsuit alleges that Apple implemented the “FaceTime Break” on April 16, 2014, blaming the sudden incompatibility on a bug, and advising users that they would need to update to the latest version of iOS to resolve the issue.


U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh said the plaintiffs in the case could proceed with their efforts to prove that they had experienced “some measurable loss to their phones’ value” because of Apple’s actions and that Apple’s conduct “constituted a trespass and violated state consumer protection laws.” One particularly damning email from an Apple employee was cited twice in the hearing, with the writer admiting that iOS 6 users were “basically screwed” by the decision to disable FaceTime on their devices, and Koh rejected Apple’s claim that there was no economic loss since FaceTime is a “free” service.


Latest News
The Apple Watch Series 11 46mm GPS Is $100 Off
The Apple Watch Series 11 46mm GPS Is $100 Off
1 Min Read
Clamshell Style iPhone Being Looked Into By Apple
Clamshell Style iPhone Being Looked Into By Apple
1 Min Read
Foldable iPhones May Have the Largest Battery Ever
Foldable iPhones May Have the Largest Battery Ever
1 Min Read
Apple and TSMC’s 10-Year Collaboration May Be Ending
Apple and TSMC’s 10-Year Collaboration May Be Ending
1 Min Read
The 13-inch M5 iPad Pro 256GB Wi-Fi Is $149 Off
The 13-inch M5 iPad Pro 256GB Wi-Fi Is $149 Off
1 Min Read
M5 Pro and M5 Max Chips for the MacBook Pro could Roll Out with macOS 26.3
M5 Pro and M5 Max Chips for the MacBook Pro could Roll Out with macOS 26.3
1 Min Read
Mac Ordering Process Revamped
Mac Ordering Process Revamped
1 Min Read
Check Signed By Steve Wozniak and Steve Jobs Sold For $2.4 Million
Check Signed By Steve Wozniak and Steve Jobs Sold For $2.4 Million
1 Min Read
The Anker 140W 4-Port GaN USB-C Charger is $35 Off
The Anker 140W 4-Port GaN USB-C Charger is $35 Off
1 Min Read
No iPhone Air 2 This Year, according to Latest Report
No iPhone Air 2 This Year, according to Latest Report
1 Min Read
New Report Corroborates Split iPhone Release Dates
New Report Corroborates Split iPhone Release Dates
1 Min Read
Apple Losing More Researchers As They Plan To Release 2 Siri Versions
Apple Losing More Researchers As They Plan To Release 2 Siri Versions
1 Min Read

iLounge logo

iLounge is an independent resource for all things iPod, iPhone, iPad, and beyond. iPod, iPhone, iPad, iTunes, Apple TV, and the Apple logo are trademarks of Apple Inc.

This website is not affiliated with Apple Inc.
iLounge © 2001 - 2025. All Rights Reserved.
  • Contact Us
  • Submit News
  • About Us
  • Forums
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms Of Use
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?